Real-Life Bishop of Ripon

Matthew & Mary Downton

Here is an interesting fact for Downton Abbey fans:

The nearby town of Ripon is a real place. It has a real Anglican bishop. During the Second Vatican Council, the Anglican Bishop of Ripon represented the Church of England in St. Peter’s. At one point, he said:

For there to be unity among Christians, there will have to be a central head of the Church, and that head will certainly have to be the Bishop of Rome.

Interesting enough, if we leave it at that.

But perhaps even more interestingly, Bishop Moorman went on to say that, in order to arrive at true collegiality among all the bishops of the Church, “some method must be provided whereby representative bishops of the whole world could form a permanent council with the Pope, which would be an improvement on the present system of a largely Italian Curia.”

Now, the system for collegiality which Vatican II envisioned–namely, the regular meeting of bishops in Synod with the Pope–has, in fact, occurred ever since the Council concluded. Also, the Curia is nowhere near as Italian as it was in 1963. Not to mention the fact that the monumental task of organizing and running Vatican II itself was largely accomplished by “the Curia.”

And yet the specter of the unhelpful, if not corrupt, “Italian Curia” remains. To my little mind, the widespread hue and cry for “Curial reform” these days rings empty, like a meaningless shibboleth.

Does it make sense to condemn a corrupt Italian Roman Curia, when the head of the most powerful dicastery has been, for almost all of the eight years of Benedict XVI’s pontificate, an American? When it has been 35 years since an Italian occupied the Chair of Peter? When “the Curia” can boast of a success as truly titanic as publishing the Catechism of the Catholic Church? When “the Curia” has had to navigate the task of ushering the vernacular into the Sacred Liturgy of the Roman Rite?

Old stereotypes die hard. I am afraid that most reporters, when they use (and mispronounce) the word “Curia,” really have no idea whatsoever what they are talking about.

Maybe we can humbly acknowledge that the real business of running the Apostolic See is a bit more complicated than largely uninformed slogans about “the Curia.”


2 thoughts on “Real-Life Bishop of Ripon

  1. lovely picture….I will read the article later ,I guess I need more time to understand it all 🙂

  2. Father Mark,

    The fourth estate surrendered its credentials in my lifetime. They have descended from being the voice that speaks for you (the public) when there’s no one else in the establishment to speak for you, to being the voice of the establishment that attempts to propagandize for those in power, and who attempt to save people from themselves by enslaving them to the establishment.

    Don’t worry about the stereotyping of the Curia, and the call for Curia Reform. Next week they’ll be on to something else, selling fear, hate and discontent in the name of news.

    Stealing from the motto of the “grey lady”: “All the fits that are news to print”.

    In God we trust.



Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s