John 6 Ecumenism

Pope Francis Jay Wright Villanova ball
Now the Pope owns the NCAA Championship ball!

Do not work for the food that perishes, but for the food that endures to eternal life. (John 6:27)

We kept the 50th anniversary of the Second Vatican Council a few years ago, between 2012 and 2015. But maybe some of Pope Francis’ more-recent teachings lead us back to the Second Vatican Council again.*

Here’s one question: Was Vatican II overly optimistic in focusing on what Protestants and Catholics have in common?

One side would say: Yes, Vatican II was wrong there. It was a betrayal of sacred Catholic Tradition and the Council of Trent to affirm that Protestants and Catholics share the same faith in Christ.

–But isn’t that’s going too far? There’s only one Jesus. And we all personally know Protestants who truly and sincerely believe in Him. So Vatican II was not altogether wrong to emphasize what we have in common.

On the other hand, the other extreme would say: No, Vatican II had no misplaced optimism whatsoever. Christian re-unification is right around the corner, if only we could get over ourselves!

–But that’s going too far, too. No reasonable observer can deny that, in spite of a lot of common enterprises, and a lot of good intentions, the last fifty years have not seen a whole lot of real ecumenical headway. Quite the contrary.

Ross Douthat To Change the ChurchDuring the third week of Easter we read from John 6 at Holy Mass. Seems to me like we Catholics could lay down this marker, and live at peace with it:

We believe that Jesus rose from the dead. And we believe that He makes Himself present on the altar at Mass to be our food unto eternal life.

It seems to us that these two aspects of the faith—namely the Resurrection and the Real Presence—are really one aspect. It makes absolutely no sense to separate them. And why would anyone want to?


*I have been reading Ross Douthat’s To Change the Church. Douthat illuminates things enormously, I think, by outlining the two alternative understandings of the past 55 years of Catholic history, “liberal” and “conservative.” But there’s more to the story, I think. And I want to try to bring it to light, as the opportunity allows.

4 thoughts on “John 6 Ecumenism

  1. People (including Protestant ministers) are converting to Catholicism and/or returning to their Catholic roots, because of what the Catholic church is and believes…danger in “watering down” beliefs in order to unite.
    Judy R.

  2. “BODY & BLOOD, SOUL & DIVINITY” TRULY PRESENT! That’s the peg I hang my very life on! It took a few years of Journey in THE Church of Rome for me to get this, and praise God this convert got it! St Paul said, if someone comes preaching a different gospel than what we shared, pay them no mind! … pro-testants have been preaching a different gospel at least since M. Luther the excommunicated priest and they have tens of thousands of “flavors” to prove their error. Been there and want no more of it.

  3. Great comments above. It should be all about God’s teaching, Scripture and God’s Divine Law – not governmental law or the beliefs of other religions. We could argue the pros and cons of
    Vatican II but one has to note that post Vatican II 50% of Catholics stopped going to church. Your first sentence, Father, is all that matters. I for one is on God’s side – being tired of the left or right side of things.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s