Increasing Sense of Helplessness

greengrass united 93

Paul Greengrass made the 9/11 movie–United 93.

Everything in the little worlds of FAA Headquarters, and Newark airport, and the regional air-control centers in New England and New York–everything began normal, a lovely late-summer morning. Then chaos, and a sense of utter helplessness, builds little by little. For two agonizing hours.

Yesterday, in holy Mother Church, the sense of utter helplessness built a little more.

Beautiful West Virginia had a bishop from Philadelphia. He used to run the Basilica of the Shrine of the Immaculate Conception, and I knew him then. He and I had a run-in with then-Cardinal McCarrick over a homily I gave at a friend’s first Mass.

Your humble servant celebrated Mass in Bishop Bransfield’s diocese just last Wednesday, the anniversary of Mother Teresa’s death, while I was on a little vacation in Berkeley Springs, WV, with my dear mother and brother.

We prayed special for Bishop Bransfield at that Mass, because his 75th birthday drew nigh. Time for a transition, since bishops must resign at that age.

Yesterday things got weird. The Pope accepted Bishop Bransfield’s resignation, effective immediately. The Archbishop of our ecclesiastical province left Baltimore to go to West Virginia. To investigate Bishop Bransfield’s evils. Without any public explanation of what those evils are.

Weirder still: The president of the US Conference of Catholic Bishops is the Archbishop of Galveston-Houston, in Texas–Daniel Cardinal DiNardo.

Eleven years ago, Texas dispensed with any statute of limitations for the criminal prosecution of sexual abuse of minors.

Cardinal DiNardo’s right-hand man for Hispanic ministry is Father Manuel LaRosa-Lopez. Turns out that he has just been arrested by the police. For alleged crimes that occurred about twenty years ago.

He was arrested while Cardinal DiNardo was in Rome to meet with the pope to plan out how to deal with the crisis.

pope dinardo gomez

Paul Greengrass could not make a movie more excruciating than this. And the worst part is the utter meltdown of effective communication.

Archbishop Lori, of Baltimore, issued a statement, touching on “the troubling allegations against Bishop Bransfield.” What allegations? Over a decade ago, an avowed pederast priest accused Bransfield of sexually abusing a minor. It was a pure-hearsay allegation. The minor himself (now an adult) testified that Bransfield had never done anything wrong.

While Cardinal DiNardo exchanged jokes with the pope, his Archdiocese of Galveston-Houston issued a defensive statement of self-contradictory bureaucratic gobbledegook to explain the Father LaRosa-Lopez affair.

Paragraph one narrates a course of events in which the principle of zero tolerance for sex abuse of minors was manifestly not followed. Then the concluding paragraph of the statement insists that the diocese simply will not tolerate sexual abuse. And the entire upshot of the statement is: If there are any problems here, it is the fault of the victims, their families, and Child Protective Services. Not our fault. At all. Not us.

…Meanwhile, the pope announced a synod of all the heads of the national bishops conferences, to deal with the crisis. In February.

What will happen? The same thing that has happened over and over again for years and years.

The pope will tell the bishops conferences that they absolutely positively have to deal with this problem. The bishops conferences will say, there’s nothing we can do. Only the Vatican can deal with this. Then everyone will congratulate each other and go home.


6 thoughts on “Increasing Sense of Helplessness

  1. No Father, God will make good from this evil. He will not let the people of God be lulled to sleep by broad sweeping generalities that have no real accountability. He permits evil but He alone sees the big picture. Watch where the people go. See who they pray for and with, watch as they stand beside the courageous. We will be present for the movement of the Holy Spirit, transforming the church – we will be there turning over the tables in the synagogue. We are ready to take back our church, don’t count us out.

  2. We have reached a tipping point. It would be impossible to return to the status quo with all that has happened. It won’t be easy, it won’t be quick, but there will be change. There are far too many voices that will not go quietly. We must pray for the Synod in February. We must keep hope and prayer at the forefront of everything we do, and trust that God will act. He has never abandoned his church, and he will not now.

  3. I hope you are wrong, Father, but I think you are right. Remember the guilty bishop in Boston that was placed in charge of a major basilica in Rome until he died? Will it be the decrease in funds that will change their mind? How do you ever solve a worldwide problem?

  4. “… an avowed pederast priest …” a sodomizer of boys? How brazen! Why am I less and less surprised? Yet I am the more surprised, pleasantly, at my growing HOPE for Holy Church and Her sincerely faithful children. Our Lord casts His Holy Light making us all see the rot in high places, by extension, the rot we each harbor in our own worldly hearts. Battle Line is being drawn on the Field. On which side will I join or will I slink over to the bleachers to watch and not deal with my own obdurate rot? I choose to face my stink, join the ranks under the command of Our Blessed Mother who has been literally ‘seen’ directing cannon fire in battles past. I rejoice at hearing a Priest of God voicing holy indignation at rot in high places, fearlessly! It has been made very, very clear that the sincerely faithful are going to be greatly persecuted for the Name of Jesus. Now is the time to set ones decision and learn to hold to it. Failing this now, when the persecution comes, there won’t be backbone enough to make the stand required for Salvation. We each have sufficient LIGHT to make Holy Choice, with or without Holy clergy! The Church in Japan survived three centuries without Priests.

  5. When I was at TC many seminarians referred to the National Shrine as the National Crime. Seems kind of prescient now, given Bransfield.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s